Screen Replacement: Frame or Frameless?
Screen Replacement: Frame or Frameless? + Expert Insights + 9 Key Differences
Cracked phone screen? You’re probably searching for a replacement screen—and now you’re staring at two options: with frame or frameless (without frame). But which one is better?
Understanding the difference can help you avoid costly mistakes, wasted time, and performance issues. Whether you’re considering a DIY approach or seeking a professional fix, this article breaks down everything you need to know.
What Is a Screen With Frame?
A screen with frame includes the LCD/OLED display pre-installed within the mid-frame (or chassis) of the phone. It’s essentially a complete front panel, ready to be attached to the rest of the device.
Also known as:
- Full display assembly
- Screen with housing
- Pre-installed screen unit
Benefits:
- Pre-aligned components
- Easier and safer installation
- Reduced chance of damaging the display during replacement
What Is a Frameless Screen Replacement?
A frameless screen is only the display panel (LCD/OLED), without the supporting mid-frame. The technician must detach the broken display from the original frame and install the new one carefully.
Also known as:
- Bare screen
- Display only
- LCD without bezel
Drawbacks:
- Requires more skill and precision
- Time-consuming
- Prone to misalignment or adhesive issues
Visual Comparison: Frame vs Frameless
| Aspect | Screen With Frame | Frameless Screen |
|---|---|---|
| Includes mid-frame | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
| Risk of breakage during install | Low | High |
| Installation time | Faster | Slower |
| Cost | Higher | Lower |
| Requires glue/heat | No (or minimal) | Yes |
| Recommended for beginners | ✅ | ❌ |
Pros of Screen With Frame
- ✅ Perfect alignment
- ✅ Maintains structural integrity
- ✅ Lower failure rate
- ✅ Easier for professional and DIY repairs
- ✅ Better support for waterproofing restoration
If you’re in a hurry or want to avoid complications, this is the safest choice.
Pros of Frameless Screen Replacement
- ✅ Cost-effective
- ✅ More widely available for certain models
- ✅ Smaller packaging for shipping
- ✅ Useful for partial repairs (screen only)
Ideal for experienced repair technicians or repair shops with re-alignment jigs and screen press tools.
Technical Skills Required for Both
| Task | Screen With Frame | Frameless Screen |
|---|---|---|
| Disassembly | Moderate | High |
| Glue/adhesive application | Minimal | Required |
| Heat gun use | Rarely | Frequently |
| Re-aligning components | Not needed | Crucial |
| Reuse of old frame | ❌ | ✅ |
Time & Complexity Differences
- With Frame: 30–45 minutes (professional)
- Frameless: 60–90 minutes or more (even for pros)
DIY Note:
Frameless screens often require heat application and risk damaging internal components if not done correctly.
Cost Comparison: Frame vs Frameless
| Phone Model | With Frame (AUD) | Frameless (AUD) |
|---|---|---|
| iPhone 11 | $260 | $180 |
| Samsung S21 | $330 | $250 |
| Google Pixel 6 | $290 | $210 |
Prices include parts only; labor not included.
Risk Factors of Frameless Replacements
- ❌ Misalignment may cause unresponsive touch
- ❌ Excess adhesive can damage internals
- ❌ Glass breakage during installation
- ❌ Face ID or fingerprint sensor failures
- ❌ Loss of waterproofing
When Should You Choose Screen With Frame?
Choose screen with frame if:
- You want long-term durability
- Your phone has waterproofing you want to retain
- You’re not confident with tools
- Your existing frame is cracked or warped
- You want a faster, smoother process
When Frameless Screens Are Acceptable
Opt for frameless screens if:
- You’re on a strict budget
- You have professional repair experience
- Your frame is in perfect condition
- The repair is not mission-critical (e.g., backup phone)
Brand and Model Variations
Some phones are easier to repair with a screen-only option:
| Brand | Frame Preferred | Frameless Feasible |
|---|---|---|
| iPhone (X and newer) | ✅ | ⚠️ Risky |
| Samsung Galaxy S Series | ✅ | ⚠️ Difficult |
| Xiaomi Redmi Series | ⚠️ Mixed | ✅ Common |
| Google Pixel | ✅ | ⚠️ Only with calibration tools |
Impact on Water Resistance
Phones with IP67/IP68 ratings lose their water resistance if:
- The adhesive is improperly applied
- The frame is not sealed correctly
- Non-genuine gaskets are used
Using a screen with frame helps maintain or restore water protection more effectively.
Durability Over Time
Screen With Frame:
- Better structural support
- Reduced stress on the screen
- Lower chance of loosening over time
Frameless:
- Can shift or lift with poor adhesive
- Susceptible to cracks around the edges
- Less shock absorption
Expert Recommendations
At Sydney CBD Repair Centre, we recommend screen with frame for 90% of screen replacements. It ensures:
- Proper alignment
- Long-term durability
- Quicker turnaround
- Higher customer satisfaction
We only use genuine parts with or without frames and always advise customers on the best option for their specific device.
FAQs
1. What’s the main difference between frame and frameless screens?
Framed screens include the mid-frame; frameless are just the screen. Framed screens are easier and safer to install.
2. Is a screen with frame more durable?
Yes. It has better alignment, stability, and long-term performance.
3. Can I reuse my old frame with a frameless screen?
Yes, but only if it’s undamaged and precisely cleaned.
4. Are framed screens more expensive?
Generally, yes—but they save you time and reduce installation risk.
5. Does screen with frame help retain water resistance?
Absolutely. It allows better resealing using original-grade components.
6. Do repair shops charge more for screen with frame?
Slightly, but it includes a faster, safer repair and typically a better warranty.
Conclusion
So, screen with frame vs frameless—what’s the final verdict?
✔️ Go with frame if you want a reliable, efficient, and durable screen replacement.
⚠️ Only choose frameless if you’re experienced, or working with a trusted technician and on a tight budget.
At Sydney CBD Repair Centre, we help customers choose the best solution tailored to their needs—no upsells, no shortcuts, just honest, expert repair services.
David from Sydney CBD Repair Centre
6-Time Winner for Best Mobile Repairs in Sydney
✓ Same-Day Repairs
✓ 2000+ 5-Star Reviews
✓ Genuine Parts with 90-Day Warranty
📍 Find Us Here
📞 Call: +61280114119
